Supercharger VS. Turbocharger
Many
people are confused about the differences between a super charger and turbocharger. Booth families of devices are basically
air compressors, but they're operated' quite differently from each other. A supercharger is mechanically driven by the engine
itself; usually off the crankshaft by a cogged belt and pulley system. This means that a supercharger uses up some of the
engine's horsepower just to drive itself - often 60 horsepower or more! Fortunately, the airflow generated by the supercharger
helps it produce far more horsepower than it requires to operate.
A turbocharger, however, is driven by the thermal
energy of the exhaust gases of the engine. With non-turbocharged vehicles, these gases are simply discharged out of the engine
as quickly and efficiently as possible, wasting a surprising amount of energy in the form of noise and heat. A turbocharger
uses some of that energy (which would otherwise be wasted) to drive its compressor, without the attendant horsepower loss
of a crankdriven system.
The result?
The
turbocharged engine stands to produce more peak horsepower than a comparable supercharged engine, mostly because the turbo
does not require any power from the crankshaft. Also, the turbocharged engine will typically run much quieter than a supercharged
engine since the turbo has no gears, belts or pulleys and because the turbo itself muffles the exhaust. And while many superchargers
are large, heavy devices (we've all seen Roots-type blowers sticking up through the hoods of muscle cars), the turbocharger
is a relatively small package - a turbo capable of producing 600 horsepower can weigh only 15 pounds and be easily held in
one hand. It is for these reasons that turbocharging has become increasingly popular with both OE and aftermarket manufacturers.
Automakers can produce lightweight vehicles with good fuel economy yet excellent power thanks to the turbo. The aftermarket
manufacturers have jumped into the game, offering larger turbocharger "upgrades" in place of factory turbos, or even complete
turbo "kits" to convert a naturally-aspirated vehicle to turbocharged configuration. One question we hear quite often at SCC
is whether a normally-aspirated engine can be turbocharged. Any engine can be turbocharged, and there are a number of turbo
kits available to allow you to do this to a variety of vehicles. However, if you cannot locate a kit for your vehicle (or
you choose not to purchase an existing kit), you can build a custom installation yourself.
The fundamentals are basically
these:
* Exhaust must be routed to the turbine inlet of the turbocharger. This is typically done with a turbo exhaust
manifold, when available, or a custom adapter plate to allow you to mount the turbo to the factory exhaust manifold.
*Exhaust
must be directed out of the turbine discharge of the turbocharger. This can typically be done at a muffler shop, where
a custom down-pipe will be fabricated, to connect the turbine discharge side of the turbo to the exhaust system.
*Air
must be ducted from the air filter to the compressor inlet, and from the compressor discharge to the intake manifold. This
is typically done in aluminum or steel tubing which is then coupled at all joints by silicone hose couplings or nitrile rubber
connectors. Flex hose is sometimes used on the inlet side of the compressor since it is only subjected to vacuum, not pressure.
*Pressurized
oil must be fed to the turbocharger's bearings. The most common place to tap into an oil galley is at the oil pressure sending
unit.
*An oil drain line must be installed so that the oil used to lubricate the turbocharger can drain back to the
oil pan. This is typically done by brazing a hose fitting to the pan and using a large diameter, oil-resistant hose from the
bottom of the turbo to the side of the pan. The heart of the turbo system is of course, the turbocharger itself. The size
and model of turbo that you require can vary radically depending on your application (i.e. street, track, drag). The larger
turbochargers can produce tremendous amounts of power, but they will take longer to spool up (turbo lag). This is a function
of the size of compressor and turbine wheels, as well as the turbine housing itself. A turbocharger applications specialist
will be able to assist you in choosing the proper turbocharger for your car.
Boost
Control Devices There are a variety of kinds of boost controls on the market. Some control air flow in
and out of the compressor (such as pop-off valves or restrictors), but the most efficient (and for this reason the most popular)
are controllers that work on the turbine side, which are known as wastegates.
As mentioned earlier in the article,
the turbine wheel is driven by exhaust gases. A wastegate functions by taking a portion of the exhaust gas that would drive
the turbine wheel and rerouting to bypass the turbine wheel. This way we can control the speed of the turbocharger and therefore,
limit the boost the turbo produces. A boost control should be used so that you can limit the total amount of boost to the
engine to prevent detonation.
There are other details to contend with, such as fuel enrichments, ignition controls,
where and why to install check valves in vacuum lines, and so on. Therefore, it will be very helpful to both you and those
helping you if you do your homework ahead of time. There are several useful books written specifically on the subject of turbocharging,
some of which are available from bookstores.
Is turbocharging safe for my engine? There
are several factors to take into account when turbocharging a vehicle. First, if the engine has high mileage and/or a good
deal of wear, your money may be better spent freshening up the rings, bearings, valve guides, etc. before you invest in a
turbo system. The additional stress put on the engine's internal components by the increase in horsepower may cause a weak
engine to expire!
Furthermore, you -should determine whether, the engine's compression ratio permits the addition of
a turbo. Since we're already compressing the charge air with the turbo, the higher the engine's static compression ratio is,
the greater the tendency toward detonation. In other words, the higher your compression, the less boost you can run.
You
must also take the fuel and ignition systems into account. I your fuel injection or carburetor going to be able to compensate
for the additional airflow generated I the turbocharger and add a corre sponding amount of fuel under boost? Is your ignition
system cap able of retarding the spark timing under boost, if necessary? Both fuel and ignition systems must be up the engine's
demands, as the incorrect fuel delivery or spark timing can cause harmful detonation( Of course, correct fuel delivery and
spark timing can make a great deal of horsepower!)
Conclusion In
our opinion, when properly installed a turbocharger system is capable of producing the best bang for the buck. When factoring
in its reasonable cost, relatively compact size and adaptability to any sport compact car, turbocharging makes a whole lot
of sense for the enthusiast seeking big time horsepower gains!
For those that can't get enough of turbo-related
goodies, check out the Turbo Club Of America. A one-year membership entitles you to club discounts on performance equipment
from participating manufacturers and six issues of Turbo Club News plus much more!
Chris Weisberg is a Turbocharger Specialist
Turbonetics, Inc., manufacturers of custom turbochargers
and controls
|